Imagine this: You're a college football coach, guiding your team to the brink of a conference championship, but your mind is split between celebrating the present and plotting your next big move. It's championship weekend in college football, and while coaches everywhere warn against distractions, this year's events are turning that advice into a tough reality. But here's where it gets controversial—coaches are juggling two jobs at once, game-planning for their current teams while sneaking in time for their upcoming roles. And this is the part most people miss: how this 'coaching carousel' is testing the very fabric of the sport's integrity during its most exciting time. Let's dive in and unpack it all, shall we?
Conference championship weekend is here, bringing with it a whirlwind of extra media scrums, heightened local buzz, intensified team scrutiny, more travel, and basically an overload of everything else. It's that special period when championships and lasting legacies hang in the balance. Yet, in 2025, things feel even more charged due to an underlying awkwardness rippling through many of the title games on Friday and Saturday. Coaches across the nation are fully immersed in leading their current squads, meticulously crafting game plans, only to carve out brief moments to shift gears for their new positions at different schools.
“I'm not shocked at all; I came into this with eyes wide open and anticipated it,” shared American Athletic Conference commissioner Tim Pernetti recently. “It really highlights a larger question about the schedule and the ideal timing for these transitions, ensuring we safeguard the postseason's purity and the game's overall integrity. This is definitely a topic commissioners will keep debating.”
For a quick refresher on the college football world: athletic directors are often eager to wrap up coaching searches as early as possible, especially in an age where players can freely transfer like free agents in pro sports. Recent adjustments to the transfer portal have eased some pressures, but Wednesday kicked off the early signing period, prompting schools to secure part of their coaching staffs to provide stability for incoming recruits and roster managers aiming to rebuild effectively.
The American Athletic Conference is the epicenter of this messy transition this season, with coaches practically changing outfits mid-day based on their 'hat'—a literal metaphor for their dual roles. Tulane's Jon Sumrall, ranked No. 20, is coaching the conference title game despite accepting Florida's head coaching job just this past Sunday. Across from him, Eric Morris is balancing his duties as North Texas's head coach (No. 24) while assembling his future team at Oklahoma State.
“Not many folks grasp the challenges we're facing or the tough choices involved,” Morris explained. “But it's kind of amazing that we're both in this boat and still steering our teams effectively. Sleep has been elusive with everything swirling in my head, but I haven't faltered in prepping the team. I'm still designing the offensive plays, leading our meetings—consistency for our players and coaches is crucial to give us a shot at victory.”
Victory isn't merely about the thrill of clinching a conference crown after a grueling season for some coaches. This Friday alone, three head coaches are striving to secure playoff spots, which would prolong this uncomfortable limbo into the new year, even as they've been lured away by powerhouse programs.
Beyond Morris and Sumrall in the American, James Madison's Bob Chesney has the Dukes at No. 25 in the latest playoff rankings, poised as heavy favorites to host the Sun Belt championship against Troy. Though not yet public, he's slated to become UCLA's next head coach but has agreed to stay in Harrisonburg, Virginia, if the team captures the title and punches a playoff ticket (a scenario that's still in play, especially with five-loss Duke battling in the ACC).
“Life-altering opportunities can arise, and you weigh them as they come,” Chesney noted. “What matters most is keeping our focus on this game. Next year is for next year; let's talk about this championship right now.”
Ideally, all eyes would be on the field, but in our social media-driven world, players are glued to their phones when not practicing. Coaches often tackle rumors head-on with their teams to nip any brewing tension before big games.
“I've urged our squad to concentrate on what we control as a unit, ignoring the noise,” said BYU's Kalani Sitake on Monday, amid buzz from Penn State before he signed a new deal to stay in Provo. “This is a distraction we can certainly live with, but we must channel everything into dominating against Texas Tech.”
“I've always valued honesty—that's why we didn't bury this Oklahoma State agreement and surprise everyone later,” Morris added. “It felt hypocritical to stand before the team otherwise. After the initial surprise wore off, our players have managed it remarkably well.”
The true test lies in this weekend's outcomes, with numerous assistant coaches eyeing their next steps and other head coaches potentially entangled in searches for the seven vacant positions.
For those in the thick of it, this is just the new normal in early December—a dynamic where the future collides with the now in an ever-shifting industry. Success often invites ladder-climbing, compressing tenures from years to mere days or hours, sometimes at the cost of added stress.
“You might encounter duties that pull your attention away, so staying focused is key,” Sumrall shared. “I'm lucky to have a stellar staff handling offenses, defenses, and special teams, freeing me up somewhat.”
Interestingly, the American conference championship marks the first matchup of departing coaches since the 2012 MAC title game, pitting Northern Illinois's Dave Doeren (en route to NC State) against Kent State's Darrell Hazell (who later joined Purdue).
Doeren departed after the win, bypassing the Huskies' BCS bowl. Hazell took a unique path, leading the Golden Flashes in their month-later postseason spot, even after his replacement was hired.
This year could see a coach tread a similar path, but with the heavier stakes of a playoff game rather than a less significant bowl show.
“Tulane giving me the chance to wrap this up with the team means a lot; I'm deeply thankful,” Sumrall said. “It's all about the players—our program is player-centric, not about any one coach. Tulane football transcends individuals.”
That's a noble mindset, but this weekend, several conference championships will spotlight these coaches—not for their journeys to the title, but for their exits. It's undeniably awkward, yet it's becoming standard in early December for a sport that embraces the chaos.
But here's where it gets controversial: Is this coaching carousel a sign of progress in a fast-paced industry, or does it undermine the loyalty and focus that championships demand? And this is the part most people miss—how players, who are often young and impressionable, navigate these shifts. Does transparency truly shield them from distraction, or does it plant seeds of uncertainty? What if we reimagined the schedule to space out hires, preserving the magic of the postseason? I'd love to hear your thoughts—do you see this as an exciting evolution of college football, or a troubling erosion of its traditions? Agree or disagree in the comments; let's discuss!
More College Football from Sports Illustrated
Tune into SI’s new college sports podcast, Others Receiving Votes, below or on Apple and Spotify. Catch the show on SI’s YouTube channel.
feed
