Your role is disappearing, but your employer offers a different position. Relief can make it tempting to focus only on staying employed. A careful comparison should also establish what work you would actually be agreeing to do.
Redeployment processes and legal consequences vary by location. In Great Britain, Acas guidance on suitable alternative employment identifies factors including pay, benefits, location, terms, skills and the similarity of the work. That is a specific legal context, not a worldwide rule.
Build a comparison around the working day
Put the current and proposed roles side by side. Record the main responsibilities, working pattern, location, reporting line and required skills. Mark unanswered points as questions rather than filling them with optimistic assumptions.
For example, a role with the same salary might involve regular evening work or a different site. Another might retain the hours but require training for unfamiliar duties. Neither difference answers the suitability question alone, but both deserve a clear discussion.
Ask the manager to walk through a typical assignment and explain who supports someone learning the role. A job title can conceal more change than a practical example does.
Confirm the process before making a decision
Request the offer and relevant dates in writing. Ask which trial or review arrangements apply, how concerns should be raised and what happens if the role proves unsuitable. Do not assume an ordinary probation period is the same as a statutory alternative-employment trial.
Accepting or refusing can affect legal rights. Get advice from the appropriate local service, union or qualified adviser before relying on a general article, particularly if a deadline is approaching. Keep the original offer and your questions together.
A useful decision record explains the actual fit: the work you can perform, the support available and the practical changes involved. It gives you something firmer than either “at least it is a job” or “the title looks different.”

